Lizzie Cook

Lizzie Cook20s, 1880s, newyork, illegaldoctor, 19thcenturySUMMARY: Lizzie Cook, age 25, died July 27, 1884 after an abortion perpetrated by Dr. Ira Richmond in Lockport, NY.

Twenty-five-year-old Lizzie Cook, daughter of farmer Joseph Cook, died suddenly on July 27, 1884, in Lockport, New York.Until shortly before her death, Lizzie had worked in a domestic in several different area homes.

Dr. Ira T. Richmond was arrested. Richmond, age 46, had come to Lockport a year earlier and opened a sanitarium, “which died for want of patronage.” This might be due to the fact that, as the Chicago Inter Ocean reported on July 30, 1884, Richmond “had a dubious character among physicians.” Some doubt was expressed in news coverage as to his credentials, because he said he had graduated from New York Medical College, but couldn’t name any of the school’s faculty.

Evidently Lizzie’s brother-in-law, William, had taken her to Richmond’s practice, where she was examined in his presence and diagnosed with dropsy and blood poisoning.

Two days later, she was put to bed at Bowen’s house at about 11:00 at night, and remained there sick for nearly three weeks before her death in the afternoon of July 27. Richmond attended to her on a daily basis, sometimes visiting more than once a day, during that time.

By Saturday evening, her body had already been packed in ice and taken to her parents’ home. She was buried on Monday morning after a large funeral.

“The secrecy in getting her body removed to her home created suspicion,” so her body was exhumed that afternoon for an autopsy that revealed signs that she had died from a surgically performed abortion.

Richmond was immediately arrested and charged with either first degree murder or first degree manslaughter, according to differing sources. He pleaded not guilty, insisting that Lizzie had not been pregnant when she died and had died of dropsy and blood poisoning. “The evidence is strong against him, however,” said the July 30, 1884 Cincinnati Enquirer. Sentiment against Richmond was so strong there fears that he would be lynched.

Lizzie’s sister, Mrs. William H. Bowen, was charged as an accessory.Richmond was reportedly blase during the proceedings, in contrast to Mrs. Bowen, who clung to her husband and children, crying as she was led away.

Why the wife was charged rather than the husband is unclear; reports might have a misprint about whether it was Mr. or Mrs. Bowen who had accompanied Lizzie to Richmond’s practice.

Adding to Richmond’s ignominy while he awaited trial was his indictment for bigamy. A woman came to the courthouse from Ontario, accompanied by her adult daughter, saying that Richmond’s real name was Ira Richmond Butler, that he was her husband, and that he had abandoned her and their child about ten years earlier. She also told the authorities, the Rochester Democrat and Chronicle reported, that back in Canada “he was engaged in reprehensible practices and was of doubtful reputation.” A local woman, identified in the Democrat and Chronicle as “Mrs. Platt” rather than as “Mrs. Richmond,” also said that he was her husband. She had given birth to his child two weeks before the Canadian wife came to town.

During Richmond/Butler’s trial, a juror took sick and fainted, causing delays and raising the possibility of a mistrial. In the end, Richmond/Butler was convicted of first degree manslaughter on October 21, 1884. I have so far been unable to determine if his Canadian wife’s testimony about his doings there was admitted into evidence. The jury recommended mercy. After requesting and being denied a new trial, Richmond/Butler was sentenced to six years of hard labor at Auburn Prison.

I have no information on overall maternal mortality, or abortion mortality, in the 19th century. I imagine it can’t be too much different from maternal and abortion mortality at the very beginning of the 20th Century.

Note, please, that with issues such as doctors not using proper aseptic techniques, lack of access to blood transfusions and antibiotics, and overall poor health to begin with, there was likely little difference between the performance of a legal abortion and illegal practice, and the aftercare for either type of abortion was probably equally unlikely to do the woman much, if any, good.

For more on this era, see Abortion Deaths in the 19th Century.

For more on pre-legalization abortion, see The Bad Old Days of Abortion


  • “Charged with Abortion”, Winona Daily Republican, Jul. 30, 1884
  • “Grave Suspicions,” Cincinnati Enquirer, Jul. 30, 1884
  • “Procured an Abortion,” Decatur (IL) Herald, Jul. 30, 1884
  • “Death by Abortion,” Chicago Inter-Ocean, Jul. 30, 1884
  • “A Doctor Held for Trial,” New York Times, Aug.14, 1884
  • “Indicted for Manslaughter,” New York Times, Sept. 13, 1884
  • “Disgrace and Death,” The Ft. Wayne (IN) Daily Gazette, Jul. 31, 1884
  • “Alleged Malpractice,” Chicago Daily Tribune, Aug. 6, 1884
  • “Released on Bail,” Chicago Daily Tribune, Aug. 19, 1884
  • “Dr. Richmond’s Charges,” Rochester (NY) Democrat & Chronicle, Sept. 5, 1884
  • “Indicted for Manslaughter,” New York Times, Sept. 13, 1884
  • “Murder in the First Degree,” Dunkirk (NY) Evening Observer, Sept. 13, 1884
  • “A Juror Suddenly Taken Ill,” Rochester (NY) Democrat & Chronicle, Oct.29, 1884
  • “A Lockport Physician Convicted of Malpractice,” Detroit Free Press, Nov. 1, 1884
  • “Criminalities,” Belleville (KS) Telescope, Nov. 20, 1884
  • “Dr. Butler’s Sentence,” Iola (KS) Register, Nov. 21, 1884












  1. 1900s
  2. 1910-1919
  3. 1920s
  4. 1930s
  5. 1940s
  6. 1950s
  7. 1960s
  8. 1970s
  9. 1980s
  10. 1990s
  11. 19th century
  12. 2000-2009
  13. 20s
  14. 30s
  15. 40s
  16. NAF
  17. abortifacient
  18. abortion
  19. abortion mill
  20. abortion mortality
  21. abortionists
  22. abortionists — female
  23. abortionists — male
  24. alabama
  25. anesthesia
  26. arizona
  27. black women
  28. botched abortion
  29. california
  30. chicago
  31. colorado
  32. connecticut
  33. cover-up
  34. death
  35. deaths
  36. deception
  37. delay in transport
  38. delay in treatment
  39. district of columbia
  40. dumped body
  41. ectopic
  42. embolism
  43. falsifying forms
  44. fetal indications
  45. florida
  46. former criminal abortionist
  47. george tiller
  48. georgia
  49. hemorrhage death
  50. hospitals
  51. illegal – doctor
  52. illegal – midwife
  53. illegal – nurse
  54. illegal – paramedical
  55. illegal – post roe
  56. illegal – unknown
  57. illegal – untrained
  58. illegal abortion
  59. illinois
  60. inadequate documents
  61. inadequate equipment
  62. inadequate resuscitation
  63. incomplete abortion
  64. indiana
  65. infection
  66. kansas
  67. legal abortion
  68. llinois
  69. louisiana
  70. maryland
  71. massachusetts
  72. maternal indications
  73. maternal mortality
  74. michigan
  75. mills
  76. missouri
  77. mortality
  78. national abortion federation
  79. new jersey
  80. new mexico
  81. new york
  82. north carolina
  83. ohio
  84. oklahoma
  85. pennsylvania
  86. planned parenthood
  87. pre-roe legal
  88. previous misconduct
  89. prostaglandin
  90. quackery
  91. questionable stories
  92. ru-486
  93. rupture
  94. saline
  95. secret abortion
  96. self-induced
  97. suicide
  98. teens
  99. texas
  100. wisconsin